I’m a little stingy with five-star ratings on Untappd, so I decided to list those with 4.75 stars as well. I have over 1500 unique check-ins on Untappd, so I thought these lists were a good representations of some of my favourites. I have to say, though, I checked in some of these quite a long time ago and never had them again—I don’t even remember all of them!

Five Stars:
21st Amendment: Hell or High Watermelon
Atwater: Vanilla Java Porter
Brasserie d’Achouffe: Mc Chouffe
The Bruery: Or Xata
Cruz Blanca: Barba Negra
Goose Island: Bourbon County Brand Stout (2016)
Goose Island: Bourbon Country Brand Stout (2015)
Het Anker: Gouden Carolus Tripel
JK’s Farmhouse Ciders: Scrumpy Organic Farm Cider
Short’s: Soft Parade
Sonoma Cider: The Anvil Bourbon Cider
St. Bernardus: Christmas Ale
Uncle John’s: Apple/Cherry Hard Cider
Une Année: Truth Against the World
Wilderen: Cuvée Clarisse

4.75 Stars:
Anderson Valley: Winter Solstice
Arcadia: Barrel Aged Shipwreck Porter
Arcadia: London Style Porter
Brasserie d’Achouffe: La Chouffe
Brewery Vivant: Wizard Burial Ground
Crooked Stave: Salvador Cybies
Cruz Blanca: Medianoche
De Struise: Pannepot Grand Reserva (2010)
Elysian: The Great Pumpkin Ale
Firestone Walker: Parabola (2017)
Goose Island: All Zeros
Goose Island: Gillian (2016)
Goose Island: Proprietor’s Bourbon County Brand Stout (2016)
Granville Island: Lions Winter Ale
J. Wakefield: Welcome to the Thunderdome
Lo Rez: Whitespace
Macedonian Thrace: Vergina Weiss
Mad Fritz: The Peacock and the Crane
Mikkeller: Beer Geek Dessert
Prairie: Christmas Bomb!
Prairie: Paradise Bomb
Silver Harbor: Cookie Monsta
Southern Tier: Pumking
Surly: Darkness (2016)
Temperance: Vanilla Might Meets Right (2017)
Terrapin: Moo-Hoo Chocolate Milk Stout
Uncle John’s: Apple/Pear Hard Cider
Uncle John’s: Melded Cider
Unibroue: Don de Dieu
Van Hansebrouck: Kasteel Cuvée du Château
Virtue Cider: Percheron